60–70% Positive Replies in 6 Months for a Stripe & Payoneer Alternative

60–70% Positive Replies in 6 Months for a Stripe & Payoneer Alternative

Company

Archway Finance

Industry

FinTech (Cross-Border Payments

for Freelancers & Agencies)

Headquarters

Sofia, Bulgaria

Niche Focus

Marketing agencies, digital freelancers,

dev shops (with clients in EU, UK, US)

The Results

The Results

360+

Opportunities Generated

$150K+

Pipeline Generated

3-4%

Overall Reply Rate

60-70%

Positive Reply Rate on Replies

Campaign Duration: 6 Months
Target Regions: India & Europe

Landing Page: VSL + Conversion-Optimized Design

Retargeting: Monthly Retargeting Campaigns
Cold Email System: 30 Domains, 90 Inboxes

The Challenge

The Challenge

Before working with us, Archway was doing cold email with less than 1% reply rate.

Their core offer was extremely strong - a 2% fee flat-rate payment platform for freelancers and agencies, but their email strategy wasn’t connecting.

They had no funnel, no personalization, and were relying only on transactional logic to drive adoption.

Most importantly, they had a warm list of previous signups who never transacted, but no system to re-engage them.

Our Approach

Our Approach

01

Hyper-Relevant Lead Targeting

● Scraped marketing agencies and dev firms from LinkedIn

● Prioritized Indian and EU-based teams frustrated with Payoneer & Stripe fees
● Used Sales Navigator to create high-intent segments

02

Personalization Strategy

● Enriched agency websites using CLAY + AI

● Extracted testimonial sections and case studies

● Generated lines like:

“Did you pay 4% in fees when collecting from [ClientName]?”

● Injected context into every email, avoiding generic messaging

03

Reply Handling & CRM Automation

● Built a dedicated landing page with:

→ VSL (script by B2B Wizards, recorded by Anton)

→ Strategically placed CTAs (sign up or book a call)
→ Bonus offers (24-48 hour urgency incentives)

● Focused on no fluff, just fast sign-up

04

Retargeting & Warm List Revival

● Monthly retargeting on cold + warm lists

● Campaigns targeting:

→ Signups who never transacted

→ Leads who replied but didn’t convert
● Reactivated $150K+ in potential transaction volume

05

Pipeline Mechanics

● Sent 2,000 emails/day across 30 domains

● Used spin tags and deliverability optimizations
● Tracked performance via Instantly.ai

● Attached assets:

→ Email stats

→ Booking calendar snapshots

The Outcome

The Outcome

Over 6 months:

3-4% reply rate, up from <1%
60-70% positive response rate, unheard of in cold outbound

● Over 360 opportunities generated, with new daily signups

● Pipeline value: $150K+, depending on customer transaction volume

● Re-engaged previously dormant leads and scaled cold outreach to new markets

● Anton’s only job was to show up on the calendar, everything else was handled

● We even use Archway ourselves, having processed over $50K in payments through the platform and counting

🔥 Systems Built for Email Crew:

🔥 Systems Built for Email Crew:

✅ AI-enriched cold emails using case studies/testimonials

✅ Hyper-personalized subject lines and copy

✅ Dedicated high-conversion landing page w/ video funnel

✅ Full retargeting setup + warm list revival

✅ Automated reply tracking + call scheduling flow

✅ Visual proof (Instantly stats + booking calendar)

📈 Campaign Highlights:

Metric Result
Emails Sent Daily 2,000
Reply Rate 3–4%
Positive Reply Rate 60–70%
Opportunities Generated 432+
Pipeline $150K+
Domains Used 30
Inbox Accounts 90
Retargeting Monthly
Landing Page Yes — VSL + Urgency CTA